Maysville, KY - 
SimplytheBest.net
Click here to see 15+ minutes of video highlights from the 10th annual Rosemary Clooney Concert!
Also, check out our 'Photo Galleries' link in the right-hand column to view the current Pet Idol contestants.
« Home     |     Local News   |   Web Features   |   State News   |   National News    |   Sports   |   Opinion   |   Lifestyles   |   Obituaries   |   Classifieds

 
  Advanced Search

Opinion:  Editorial

No favoritism for Treasurer
Friday, June 20, 2008 11:56 AM EDT Print this story | Email this story
Mason County Treasurer Peggy Heflin is putting her pens and ledgers on the shelf and heading into well-deserved retirement.

Heflin's announcement of her plans earlier this week to Mason County commissioners and to Judge-Executive Buddy Gallenstein brought up a subject that deserves attention from commission and every other county office which will surely face a similar issue at some point: Who should fill the soon-to-be empty position?

Gallenstein suggested what would be an easy fix -- promote the No. 2 person in the treasurer's office to take over Heflin's position and elevate the No. 3 person to No. 2. That would leave an opening in the No. 3 slot and finding someone to fill an entry level position would be much easier, saving the county the time and trouble it might take to find multiple candidates with the qualifications for the top slot.

We have an even better idea -- open the job for applications and give every interested and qualified candidate a shot.

Gallenstein's plan may have merit, but it represents a throw-back to the way government jobs were filled in the past. Only those who had some kind of ties with elected officials or the office where the vacancy was expected were given serious consideration. In fact, in the "good old days," few people were even aware there was a job opening before it was filled. That means the general public, the taxpayers and voters weren't given fair consideration for a job which they were, in fact, funding.

When elected officials are passing out county-controlled jobs, favoritism on any level should not play a role in the decision, whether it is through nepotism or an ill-conceived notion that someone has a "right" to the job because of tenure.


Only the best qualified candidates, found through a fair and open search process, should be considered for jobs which are being funded by taxpayers. And the only way to achieve that is to seek those candidates by advertising the job opening. And who knows, maybe No. 2 will turn out to be No. 1 for the job.

We urge Gallenstein and commissioners to fill the treasurer's position, a job that pays an annual salary in the $45,000-$50,000 range through an impartial and unrestricted process that will not only ensure the office continues to uphold the standards set by Heflin, but also guarantees that county business is conducted in full view of those who have the most invested in it -- those who call this county home.


Reader Comments

Comments are limited to 200 words or less.

Evie wrote on Oct 10, 2008 3:19 PM:

" Amen, Sandra. Maysville is made up of certain groups or factions that control most things. You either belong to a certain church or family. Or you're someone's drinking or golf buddy. It's not a secret. Everyone knows it.
If you don't really care either way, you stay. I chose to leave simply because this town has nothing to offer most professionals. You realize it even more once you move away. I love the family and friends I have in Maysville, I just have no desire to move back. "

Ellen wrote on Sep 5, 2008 1:33 PM:

" I am sorry but that is the way the cookie crumbles. It is hard to land a job anywhere if you don't know someone who knows someone. There is no such thing as equal job opportunity. Favoritism has always been a factor. "

On the outside wrote on Jul 18, 2008 12:31 PM:

" The position of County Treasurer is not one that will be taken lightly by any Mason County Fiscal Court member. This is a position that requires direct experience and involvement in local government to properly understand what is required. Also, government entities operate differently at different levels city, county, and state. These requirements are mandatory and cannot be taken lightly or overlooked. A small mistake can create major problems. Promoting from within is the best way for Mason County Fiscal Court to ensure that it's financial status remains positive and secure. Also, many may not be aware, but Mrs. Heflin has set very high standards for Mason County's Treasurers Office due to her involvement in many state-wide organizations. Through her leadership and communication, Mason County has established a great reputation for being compliant and also serves as a wealth of knowledge for those that are new to local government. It only makes sense that someone that has served alongside Mrs. Heflin for numerous years, and is aware of how local government operates, should "fill her shoes". Mason County needs someone that is experienced and properly trained on these issues, not just someone that is familiar with local finances. "

citizen wrote on Jun 25, 2008 6:42 PM:

" The writer of this editorial left out some information on the position of County Treasure.
1. It is not an elected job but a job that is appointed by the Judge Executive with the approval of the commissioners.
2. It is not a secure job because if someone else wins the Judge Executive office, the new Judge has the choice of putting someone else in as treasure.
3. The treasure's office did advertise for the entry level position.It was in your paper and opened to anyone who wanted to apply.
4. You imply that the present Judge and Commissioners have something to hide because they promoted within. This a slap to them and to the No. 2 person. These gentlemaen have been elected to serve the best interest of Mason County. Do you write an editoral every time the Governor or President appoints someone to a job?
5.Last but not least, if you think these men, who call Mason County their home and are proud to do so, are less invested in the County than the gereral public, then you know absolutely nothing about them. "

Ken wrote on Jun 25, 2008 7:05 AM:

" Promote within. Its the only sensible thing to do "

Real fairness wrote on Jun 24, 2008 10:35 PM:

" Favoritism, as you call it, is called job-experience by everyone else.

You essentially printed in your paper that whoever is currently in position No. 2 isn't somehow qualified for the job. That's a very public slap in the face for whoever the unfortunate soul is that currently occupies that position. Now if they do get the job, everyone will think it's favoritism instead of... I don't know, maybe they earned it?

Favoritism and nepotism is a problem when there's a vacant position that nobody is in line to fill. When there's no one around that's qualified, and someone just hires a buddy instead of looking for qualified applicants, then you may complain. When there is someone who is qualified, trained, and waiting in line, and you say it's better to do an open casting call, you're not promoting fairness, you're promoting dead-end jobs. Dead-end public service jobs are not good for the community. There's no incentive to care about your job.

Where do you expect No. 2 to go to advance their career, another county? Perhaps you should research what it costs to hire and train an employee before you recommend wasting taxpayer's money. All the time, effort, and money Mason County spent training No. 2 is essentially wasted if you force them to go somewhere else to continue their career.

You guys should really apologize to whoever it is in position No. 2, do your your homework and see if they are a qualified candidate for the job, and then endorse them if they are, like you endorse candidates in elections when you like them. You should do that first, instead of encouraging outrage over a hypothetical unfairness. "

pleassse wrote on Jun 21, 2008 11:24 PM:

" giving the job to No. 2 is no different than this paper showing favoritism to the commonwealth attorney.....and this will not be printed... "

Sandra wrote on Jun 21, 2008 10:30 PM:

" One only has to look to Knoxville, TN for the mess that political appointments can cause. Nepotism, favoritism, the good ole boy network. Just goggle Knoxville mayor Ragsdale, Cynthia Finch and associates.
One of the reasons Maysville/Mason County has lost so many good people is the total lack of job opportunities and when a good job opens up, it is filled by the buddy system, not who is most qualified. "


Add your own comments:

(optional)
   


Copyright © 2009 Maysville Newspapers, Inc., A Lee Enterprises Publication

This site is protected by applicable copyright laws and no part may be reproduced, transmitted or used in any way other than its intended purpose without the prior written permission of The Ledger Independent.
Click here to view The Ledger Independent's privacy policy.
Click here to view current print advertisements.


  Photo Galleries
  Local Links
  Calendar
  Yellow Pages
  Real Estate
  Kentucky Crosswords
  Movie Listings
  Kentucky Lottery
  Ohio Lottery

  Subscribe
  About Us
  Place a
Classified Ad

  Birth Announcement
  Engagement Announcement
  Wedding Announcement

  Adams County
  Bracken County
  Fleming County
  Georgetown, Ohio
  Lewis County
  Ripley, Ohio